Sangtani

By Gaurav Sangtani · Module 02

The Art of
Feedback

The conversations that change behaviour, build trust, and develop people — without damaging the relationship.

The Essentials of Feedback

Six principles that separate feedback that changes people from feedback that just upsets them.

01

What Feedback Actually Is

Feedback is not criticism. It is not praise either. It is specific, observable information given to someone about the effect their behaviour has — with the intent of helping them grow or reinforcing what works.

Done well, feedback is one of the most powerful development tools a leader has. Done poorly, it damages trust, creates defensiveness, and changes nothing.

Definition
02

Why Leaders Avoid Giving Feedback

  • Fear of conflict or damaging the relationship
  • Not knowing how to frame it without sounding harsh
  • Hoping the problem will resolve itself
  • Giving vague praise instead of specific observation
  • Saving it all for annual reviews — by which point it is too late
  • Not believing feedback will change anything
Common Traps
03

The SBI Framework

The most reliable structure for any piece of feedback — positive or developmental:

  • Situation — When and where did this happen? Ground it in a specific moment.
  • Behaviour — What exactly did the person say or do? Describe the observable action, not intent.
  • Impact — What was the effect on you, the team, or the outcome? Own your reaction.

No assumptions. No labels. No "you always" or "you never".

Framework
04

Reinforcing vs. Redirecting Feedback

Most leaders give too little reinforcing feedback and deliver redirecting feedback too vaguely. Both types matter and both follow the same SBI structure.

  • Reinforcing — Anchors a behaviour you want repeated. Not "great job" — specific enough that the person knows exactly what to keep doing.
  • Redirecting — Addresses a behaviour that needs to change. Not an attack on character — an observation about a specific action and its effect.
Two Types
05

Timing, Setting and Frequency

  • Give it soon — Feedback loses impact the longer you wait. Within 48 hours is ideal for most situations.
  • Private for developmental, public for reinforcing — Never redirect someone in front of their peers.
  • Make it regular — One-off feedback feels like an event. Frequent, small pieces feel like coaching.
  • Ask first — "Can I share an observation?" increases openness dramatically.
Delivery
06

The Feedback Mindset Shift

The leaders who give the best feedback see it not as a corrective intervention — but as a gift of attention. It says: I noticed what you did. I care enough to tell you. I believe you can do better.

A team that receives regular, honest feedback develops faster, makes fewer repeated mistakes, and trusts their leader more — not less.

The discomfort of giving feedback is always smaller than the cost of not giving it.

Mindset
1 / 6

How Well Do You Give Feedback?

Eight questions to reveal your feedback patterns and how they land with your team.

Question 1 of 8

How often do you give specific, behavioural feedback to your team members?

Question 2 of 8

When you give developmental feedback, how specific are you about the behaviour?

Question 3 of 8

How do you handle a situation where someone is underperforming repeatedly?

Question 4 of 8

How much reinforcing (positive) feedback do you give compared to redirecting (developmental) feedback?

Question 5 of 8

When you give feedback, how does the recipient typically respond?

Question 6 of 8

How soon after an event do you typically give feedback?

Question 7 of 8

Do you ask for permission before giving developmental feedback?

Question 8 of 8

How do you follow up after giving developmental feedback?

0%

Build Better Feedback

A breakdown of the SBI model, when to use each feedback type, and an interactive builder to craft your next conversation.

The SBI Model — Situation, Behaviour, Impact

SBI is the gold standard for feedback delivery because it removes vagueness, reduces defensiveness, and focuses on facts rather than judgements. Each element does a specific job — remove one and the feedback loses its power.

S
Situation

Ground the feedback in a specific, recent moment. This prevents the recipient from dismissing it as a vague pattern or feeling ambushed by something they cannot recall.

"In this morning's client presentation..."
B
Behaviour

Describe only what was observable — what was said or done. No interpretations, no motives, no labels like "rude" or "disengaged". Just the action itself.

"...you interrupted the client twice while they were speaking..."
I
Impact

Share the effect that behaviour had — on you, the team, the client, or the outcome. Own it with "I noticed" or "it meant that". This is not blame — it is consequence.

"...and I noticed the client became quieter and stopped asking questions."

The Four Feedback Contexts

Reinforcing Feedback

Anchors a specific behaviour you want repeated. More than "good job" — it names exactly what was done and why it mattered. Creates conscious competence.

Reinforce

Redirecting Feedback

Addresses a behaviour that needs to change. Not a character judgement — a specific observation about an action and its effect, followed by a clear alternative.

Redirect

Developmental Feedback

Forward-looking. Focuses on building a capability over time rather than correcting a single incident. Often best delivered in a 1:1 coaching conversation.

Develop

Formal Review Feedback

Structured and documented. Should never contain surprises — everything in a formal review should already have been said informally. The review is a summary, not a reveal.

Formal

When to Give Feedback — a Timing Guide

Within 48hrs

Ideal for most feedback — both reinforcing and redirecting. The event is fresh, context is clear, and behaviour change is most likely.

Before next similar event

If the person is about to repeat the same situation (another presentation, another client call), give the feedback before it, not after.

Within the week

Acceptable for minor observations or when the person needs time to decompress first. Still useful, but impact fades with each passing day.

Weeks later

The person cannot connect the feedback to a clear memory. It feels like an ambush. Avoid unless part of a pattern you are formally documenting.

Only at reviews

Annual or quarterly-only feedback is one of the most common leadership failures. It is too infrequent to drive development and too delayed to feel relevant.

Feedback Builder

Fill in the three SBI fields below to generate a complete, ready-to-use feedback statement.

Your Feedback Statement